Penfield, NY, homeowners trust Felgemacher Roofing & Siding to keep their roofs in fine shape and looking great. A question many of our customers ask us – and rightly so – is whether their roof issues can be resolved with timely roof repairs or if a complete roof replacement is needed.
Here’s how we answer that question.
When Is Roof Repair the Right Option?
Roof repair is sometimes all that’s needed in the following scenarios:
- There’s rotting along the edge of the roof
- Some of the shingles are ripped or missing
- You’ve noticed isolated water stains on your walls and ceiling (this could also point to a chimney leak)
- There is minor sagging in the roof
- Sections of algae on the roof
These issues can often be fixed with repair work. We do all types and levels of roof repair for our Penfield, NY, customers.
Roof Inspection Penfield, NY
Only a proper roof inspection will tell us the condition of your roof. That means not just the parts you can see but also the parts below the shingles.
In extreme cases, such as after a destructive wind storm or when the roof is very old, a roof replacement is usually the answer. But for “minor” damage, we want to perform an inspection to determine whether roof repair is the right solution.
We’ll go over our inspection report with you so you can understand exactly what we found and why we’re recommending either repair or replacement.
Emergency Service
Call Felgemacher first for emergency roof repair following a serious storm. We’ll tarp your roof to protect it and then follow up with an inspection to determine exactly what needs to be done to get it back into shape.
When Do You Need a Roof Replacement?
We’ll only recommend a roof replacement if repairing it would be “throwing good money after bad.” Below are some of the cases where a new roof is recommended.
Roof age
If your roof is more than 15 years old and has many problems, it’s time to consider replacing it.
Ongoing and widespread leaks
Failing roofs will typically leak in many places. The eventual result can be damage to the roof’s decking and underlayment and possibly the truss system. Parts of the home may also be affected.
Major sagging and dips
Large areas of sagging probably mean the roof needs to be replaced. While the shingles may be in decent shape, much of what’s beneath them isn’t.
Unsightly appearance
The way a roof looks isn’t as important as how well it performs, but looks do matter. Homeowners often choose to replace very old roofs to beautify their homes and enhance their properties’ visual appeal.
It Pays to Work with Professionals
Since our family began its chimney service company in the Rochester, NY, area in 1953, the Felgemacher name has been associated with quality, honesty, and open communications. Those values direct everything we do at Felgemacher Roofing & Siding.
We’re 100% family-owned and fully insured for your protection. We’re licensed to perform roof repairs and replacements in Penfield, NY, and throughout Monroe County, NY. We know how to treat our customers right.
How Can I Find a Roofer Near Me?
If your roof is giving you problems, call the roofing experts at Felgemacher. Reach us by phone or through our contact form.

